How do you get a gold star on here! I have a nice set up with my camera, played 17 games of EQ and still no star

I can only tell you that I have been on WDA for just over a week. Played 13 EQ games over 3 nights and got a gold star. I know this doesn't help you but use as a frame of reference if you contact WDA. 

I think it's got something to do with the smiley faces at the end of your game your opponent has to grade you by sliding the marker higher on the game, hence more smiley faces good luck don't forget to ask the to grade you it's important for everyone playing